I think it is a sound proposal, I also agree with Shroom that you may want to create something like a post limit to prevent trolling though (I'd prefer capcha to a post limit, but that's just my preference).Can we suggest reading material to whoever is appointed to select the books? (Doctor FeelGood I presume ;-))I would also urge any participants to be circumspect about mentioning when/where they obtained a particular book. The eye of Sauron is really out there strobing the forum!