I think it'd be a valuable resource if we create and maintain a detailed reading list - compiled for the benefit of all. I realized that we, as a community, lack this kind of resource.
Please provide constructive criticism, and try not to be a dick.
You are more than welcome to post an item, and provide a critique (probably the best method IMHO) - this way, you've read it and thought about the contents. Alternatively (for those already well-read in the area) you can just compile lists of your own.
I'll start:
INFOSEC PRO GUIDE: CRYPTOGRAPHY, by Sean-Philip Oriyano
'Information Security: The Complete Reference', by Mark Rhodes-Ousley