We cannot and would not silence someone simply because we might be "pissed off" with what they are saying! a) There is no evidence of scamming. b) You cannot silence someone because you disagree with them. If they are scamming people, and those people report it and an investigation concludes that the claims are valid then the vendor will lose their vending privileges. You state yourself that you have never even bought anything from this person, but received a copy of something they are selling second-hand. Vendors are free to sell anything that they wish as long as it does not fall under anything in the very small "restricted items" list - the vendor in question is selling guides, and members that buy it seem happy. I just had a look and there is NO bad feedback on any of the guides on offer spanning the last 4 months, meaning that nobody - including the person you say sent you the guide - had reason to complain about it. Libertas