It's been a kinda crazy past few days. I really thought we had thought through the implications of the various proposed changed. I even opened up the discussion here to talk about what we were planning and if it would be an issue. I guess you never know until the rubber meets the road. I think we are getting closer to where this phase of the overhaul needs to be. Some concerns that were raised: Reviews for specific items should be on the item's page. They are back The design is ugly and hard to navigate. it has been slimmed down the buyer stats reveal too much. they have been rounded down to the nearest power of 10 (1+, 10+, 100+, etc) and capped at $10k (or equivalent), 100 orders, and 100 vendors, and account age has been removed completely. Keep in mind you can still change your alias to something other than your username and are encouraged to do so. No one is leaving written reviews. a link now appears on the order page immediately after a review is left prompting the user to write a written review. also, there is a link on the account page that brings up the most recent un-reviewed transaction I'm not ready to make any changes to the new policy that ratings and reviews can't be edited. If we do anything, I'm leaning toward allowing the buyer to delete a rating or review. Thank you everyone for your input with all of this. It's hard to please everyone and not everyone's desires are feasible, but I think we can find a new balance that meets most people's needs and fixes the problems we've been plagued with for so long.