So i visit one legal newsgroup that is members only and created the Google account just using a regular email, not gmail. Just need to put a name (which can be fake) and an email and you can access the newsgroups. Asks for things like phone number or back up emails but you don't have to give these. Easy to use normally but haven't used one with tor yet. There is one members only one i visit but would prefer to be anonymous when using it from now on. So if I create a new tormail only for that group (which i have visited on clearnet before and logged into with another email), and used that tormail for the Google account, would that be safe? My main concern is that I've used the website and logged in with a different email through clearnet, and don't want to accidentally unmask myself by using this site on tor.
So i was more wondering if that would be safe, if there was anything inherently in Google or those newsgroups which would make using tor a bad idea with it (like how it is not the best idea to use Facebook with tor).
Thanks for any help, am still learning so sorry if the question is stupid :/
You could be linked to your clearnet identity through information that you provide about yourself, or through your writing style. It is surprisingly easy to link some people, if they have unique patterns or quirks in their writing style. One person on this forum was linked because he wrote "a lot" as "allot". That's a very unique way to misspell it, and I presume his spellchecker didn't catch it because "allot" is a real word. Generally, the more correct, normal and mundane you write, the harder it is to find signatures or "fingerprints" in your writing style, at least for amateur readers. Professional stylometrists might be able to perform statistical attacks on your writing, looking at things like word frequency, to match your anonymous and clearnet identities, but it's unlikely you have to worry about someone like that.
No offense, but you do have a non-standard and non-correct writing style, so I would advise against it.
I may have just answered my own question now, as when I tried to go to the main Google newsgroup site, it tells me that I need to have JavaScript enabled to use the site which I am pretty sure is not okay to enable? I was under the impression it was never safe to turn JavaScript on with tor, so it still wouldn't be safe if you turned java on for the newsgroup and off for silk road?
JavaScript increases the attack surface against you, but I don't think Google is in the business of deanonymizing its users. The main reason being that a lot of people in censored countries use Tor and other proxies to access Google. Google wants them to access its sites. If it bugged its Flash video player on YouTube to connect over clearnet, the Iranian government could potentially see that connection. If someone was uploading a video of Iranian officials committing crimes, that could get them killed. Google can't take that chance, so I don't think they are in that game. Plus the general attitude that I've seen from people like Mike Hearn, a Google employee who has posted on the Tor mailing lists, is that they have no problem with anonymous users. The barrier to creating an account is mostly to stop spammers.